Showing posts with label competition. Show all posts
Showing posts with label competition. Show all posts

Friday, November 12, 2010

Beta Sigma Phi's Philosophy

It was the last Lunch Hour Concert of the year. This always takes the form of a competition between four top students at the Conservatorium. This year it was two pianos, a cello and a flute.

The first and second prizes are donated by Beta Sigma Phi, a group of ladies with eighteen hundred dollars to spare. The winner gets twelve hundred dollars and the runner up gets six. The two finalist prizes are donated by the Elder Conservatorium and are worth three hundred dollars each.

By this you can see that the Elder Conservatorium doesn't really like Beta Sigma Phi's philosophy. They could save a hundred and fifty dollars by continuing the diminishment of prize money, but they don't.

This year I thought I'd picked the winner. It was the flute girl. She walked on stage wearing an unbecoming dress. It was long and shiny and several shades of purple, and was gathered unnaturally at the front. Her hair was brown and crinkly, and flat on top. She wore glasses, and carried a flute.

Now this is all very well you are thinking, but the competition is not about looks.

I know.

My reason for mentioning looks is that by the end of her two pieces I was of a different opinion, and thought her hair and dress were quite delightful. Any one who can work that sort of transformation with a flute deserves to win .

But no. My flute girl only got three hundred dollars.

Tuesday, February 24, 2009

Examples

Yes, I admit I could have chosen a better example, but you led me into it.

I did?

You did. When you referred birds pecking at a painting of a bunch of grapes.

Ah yes, that is my favourite art anecdote, the competition between the 2 Greek painters, Parrhasius and Zeuxis. Parrhasius paints a bunch of grapes so well that birds come down to peck at them. Parrhasius is certain that he's won, but he asks Zeuxis to pull back the curtain to reveal his painting. The curtain is my painting, says Zeuxis. Then you win, says Parrhasius. I only fooled the birds, but you have fooled me.

It is a wonderful anecdote, but what are we to learn from it?

That the best art is the truest.

Or the trickiest. Let me now choose another example to illustrate the relevance of film art. Imagine a framed image on a wall. An image of a darkened room. For a while, nothing happens. Suddenly a light comes on in a corner of the room. A man enters, holding a book. He sits down. He opens the book to page 470. We see a closeup of the man's face. He looks like he has just heard a gunshot.

May I ask what you propose this as an example of?

Sorry. One upmanship.